pêche au thon impacts oceans stocks surpêche

Tuna Fishing and Its Impact on the Oceans: What You Need to Know

Tuna fishing and its impact on the oceans have been at the heart of global environmental concerns for decades. Tuna, the iconic fish of warm and temperate seas, is now one of the most heavily exploited and most threatened marine species on the planet. From Japanese sushi to salade niçoise and everyday sandwiches, our appetite for tuna has a direct effect on the health of our oceans. 🐟

Tuna fishing and its impact: the state of global stocks

Scientists at the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) have been sounding the alarm for years. Of the five main commercially fished tuna species, three are classified as overfished or close to it. Atlantic bluefin tuna remains the most publicized example: its population plunged by more than 60% between the 1970s and 2010, before strict management measures allowed numbers to recover slightly. But the situation is still fragile, and quotas are regularly contested by fishing nations.

Bigeye, albacore and skipjack tuna are also under heavy pressure. Skipjack accounts for about 60% of the world’s tuna catch — it ends up in most cheap canned tuna — and its stocks in some oceans are declining at a worrying rate. Only Pacific yellowfin tuna still enjoys relatively healthy stocks.

Fishing methods and their environmental impact

The fishing method used largely determines the impact on the oceans. Purse seining with FADs (fish aggregating devices, artificial floating rafts that attract tuna) is now the dominant method for canned tuna. It is extremely efficient but also highly unselective: up to 40% of the catch can be bycatch — juvenile tuna, sea turtles, sharks, manta rays.

At the other end of the spectrum, pole-and-line fishing — practiced notably by Basque and Breton fleets — is far more selective. It targets mature tuna one at a time, generates almost no bycatch and uses no FADs. Its impact on marine ecosystems is incomparably lower, which is why this method is central to discussions about sustainable fishing.

Bluefin tuna: a textbook case of overfishing

North Atlantic bluefin tuna has become the global symbol of overfishing. Adults can weigh more than 600 kg (1,300 lb) and live up to 40 years — which makes the species especially vulnerable to overexploitation, since the breeding adults are also the most sought after. Japanese demand for top-grade sashimi has driven bluefin prices to extravagant levels: a single fish can fetch several hundred thousand euros at Tokyo’s Toyosu market.

This extraordinary economic value creates intense commercial pressure that makes quota negotiations especially bitter. ICCAT, which manages Atlantic stocks, has repeatedly set quotas above scientific recommendations under pressure from fishing nations — a situation that nearly led to the stock’s collapse. Management measures adopted since 2010 have brought improvements, but scientists remain cautious about how lasting the recovery will be.

Labels and certifications: finding your way

Given how complex the situation is, sustainability certifications are a valuable guide for consumers. The MSC (Marine Stewardship Council) label guarantees that tuna comes from a fishery assessed and certified as sustainable, with stock management practices and limits on bycatch. However, some NGOs criticize the MSC for certifying FAD-based purse seine fisheries — practices many consider incompatible with sustainability.

The “pole-caught” or “line-caught” (pole & line) label is considered the most demanding standard in terms of environmental impact. French brands such as Phare d’Eckmühl, Belle-Iloise and Coroya sell pole-caught tuna, usually at a higher price but with a far smaller impact on marine ecosystems.

What should you buy?

For shoppers who care about the impact of their purchases on the oceans, a few simple rules apply. Avoid bluefin tuna in all its forms (with very rare exceptions for certified bluefin). Choose albacore (white tuna) caught by pole or line in the Northeast Atlantic. For canned tuna, look for MSC labels combined with the words “pole-caught” or “FAD-free.” Cutting back on tuna overall and replacing it with less threatened local species — mackerel, sardines, anchovies — is also a very effective option.

Responsible fishing exists for tuna, and it deserves to be supported by what we buy. Every carefully chosen can sends an economic signal to manufacturers and retailers in favor of more sustainable practices.

International governance: a major political challenge

Managing tuna sustainably is above all a challenge of international governance. Tuna migrate thousands of kilometers across the exclusive economic zones of many countries and the high seas — which makes managing them extremely complicated politically. The five regional tuna management organizations (ICCAT, CCSBT, IATTC, WCPFC, IOTC) often struggle to impose science-based quotas in the face of national economic interests.

The High Seas Treaty adopted at the United Nations in 2023 is an important step toward stronger protection for migratory species such as tuna on the high seas. Its effective implementation, combined with tighter controls on illegal fishing, could contribute significantly to rebuilding tuna stocks in the coming decades.